At SmartHomePerfected our information is accurate and unbiased. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

ecobee and Nest smart thermostats are two of the most sought after smart thermostats. With these brands leading the industry, when making a purchase, it is essential to know what sets them apart.

By analyzing their installation method, style, cost, learning capabilities, smartphone app, and more, we breakdown the similarities and differences between these devices.

ecobee vs Nest? Let’s dive right in!

Smart Thermostats Head to Head

Smart Thermostats – ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control vs Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation

Verdict Paragraph

9.3

ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control

Supports multiple sensors

Model(s): ecobee4

The ecobee Smart Thermostat with Voice Control is very highly rated and seen as the main competitor to the Nest.

With an in-built Alexa speaker, the device allows you to position the multi-purpose sensors in every room of your house for the convenience of controlling the temperature around you.

Pros

  • Well balanced inbuilt speakers
  • Dual-band WiFi
  • Built-in Alexa

Cons

  • Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
9.3

Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation

Ideal for using with other Nest products
vs

Model(s): T3007ES

Nest has led the way in producing beautifully designed products that stand out. Thermostats were previously a boring home fixture but Nest has helped change our perspective in the space.

This model has the ability to program itself, which helps you to save energy whenever you are not around. You can also control this smart thermostat from any location.
The Nest Learning Thermostat’s sleek design with its sharp display is an attractive feature to add to any home.

Pros

  • Offers improved learning capabilities
  • Saves energy with the auto-away feature
  • Large and sharp display

Cons

  • Does not offer a touchscreen feature

Installation

ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control
9.3
Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
9.3

Compatibility is crucial when it comes to installing your smart thermostat. 

Nest and ecobee thermostats are designed for HVAC systems with low voltage thermostats. They are incompatible with high voltage / line voltage systems. You can consult their websites to help you determine the compatibility of your thermostat and your specific HVAC system.

C-Wire

ecobee thermostat requires a C-wire to install it. However, the package comes with a Power Extender Kit (PEK). If you already have a C wire in your HVAC system, this might be the most straightforward thermostat to install. The C wire present in new HVAC systems ensures there is a constant power flow to your thermostat.

The Nest thermostat will work with most 24-volt systems. The best part of Nest installation is its ability to work with home systems without the common (C) wire however it is still necessary in 10-15% of cases.

The Nest supports whole-home humidifiers, dehumidifiers and dual-fuel systems, however a professional is recommended for these configurations to avoid encountering problems.

Smartphone App

Both ecobee and Nest thermostats come with an app that makes installations easy. You will need to download the app from the app store on iOS devices or the Google Play store on Android devices. Then follow the installation guidelines.

Style, Design & Price

ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control
9.2
Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
9.4

Although Nest beats most smart thermostats in the market for design, you cannot dispute ecobee’s elegant look. The smart device comes with a vivid touch screen with a crisp glass finish. Besides, ecobee has a touchscreen display which Nest lacks. The display is also wider to provide a variety of information.

The Nest is considered to be the best-designed thermostat that looks great on most wall decorations. The beautiful device with steel components remains unique with its modern round look. Additionally, Nest smart thermostat comes with a high-resolution glass display.

You can opt for a stainless steel or polished steel finish. The manufacturer also brings you black, black mirror, white, copper, and black options.

Price

Generally speaking, both the Nest and ecobee thermostats are relatively expensive compared to digital programmable thermostats or simpler smart thermostats (such as the Honeywell T9). You might find them worth the price if you consider their great smart functionality, ease of use, and their integration with your smart home ecosystem.

Programming and Learning Capabilities

ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control
9.2
Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
9.4

ecobee comes with a traditional scheduling system. This allows you to set your system to exactly what you want.  You can set up the temperatures for home, away, and sleeping mode throughout the week. You get some amazing energy reporting with ecobee.

With the ecobee app, you don’t need to rely on the device to set up your schedule. You can also use the web console. Once you set it up, the device will operate under the same programming until you manually change the scheduling.

Learning Algorithm

On the other hand, Nest comes with one of the most advanced scheduling features. This is seen in the thermostat’s ability to learn your schedules and routines automatically with no need to set the devices programme. This might make the difference for an individual with a busy schedule.

What if I want to adjust the temperature in the house? You can simply adjust the dial and as you make little changes, it dynamically adjusts the future schedule to cater for your adjustments.

Smart Features & Integrations

ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control
9.5
Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
9.2

When it comes to voice control, ecobee can work with all three principal voice assistants (Alexa, Siri and Google Assistant)

Above all, it has a built-in Alexa speaker. This means you don’t need other smart devices that support voice commands. 

Nest, on the other hand, only works with Google Assistant and Alexa. Therefore, you may be at a disadvantage if you use Siri as there is no native support.

With these integrations, you can control your thermostat through the Alexa / Google Home app or simply by speaking.

Geofencing

Nest beats ecobee when it comes to geofencing. The device contains native geofencing utilizing the location of multiple phones. It also works well with other Nest devices.

This is opposed to ecobee that basically supports geofencing for only one phone. In order to enable it to work with multiple phones, you will need to do a little more work to utilize a third-party app.

Sensors

Another smart feature that these devices exhibit are room sensors. ecobee sensors are capable of recording temperature and motion which is different to the add-on Nest sensors, which only monitor temperature.

Technical Comparison (ecobee vs Nest)

ecobee4 Smart ThermostatNest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
Part Numberecobee4T3016US
ColorBlackStainless Steel
Item Weight1.72 pounds1 pound
WiFiYesYes
Bluetooth ModeNoYes
HVAC compatibilityHighHigh
GeofencingSupports only one phoneSupports multiple phones
Algorithmic learningNoYes
In-built voice controlYesNo
Amazon AlexaYesYes
Google assistantYesYes
Apple HomekitYesNo
Batteries requiredNoNo
Battery typeInternal batteryInternal battery
Sources: store.google.com, ecobee.com

The Verdict

In the battle of ecobee vs Nest … It’s a tie!

Both devices have impressive feature sets, they both look the part, and would be a welcome addition to any home.

For advanced reporting and a built-in Alexa speaker, the ecobee may be the choice for you. Or if you like the thoughts of the self-learning functionality of the Nest, then that is a worthy choice.

Over to you!

9.3

ecobee4 Smart Thermostat with Voice Control

Supports multiple sensors

Model(s): ecobee4

The ecobee Smart Thermostat with Voice Control is very highly rated and seen as the main competitor to the Nest.
With an in-built Alexa speaker, the device allows you to position the multi-purpose sensors in every room of your house for the convenience of controlling the temperature around you.

Pros

  • Well balanced inbuilt speakers
  • Dual-band WiFi
  • Built-in Alexa

Cons

  • Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation
9.3

Nest Learning Thermostat 3rd Generation

Ideal for using with other Nest products
vs

Model(s): T3007ES

Nest has led the way in producing beautifully designed products that stand out. Thermostats were previously a boring home fixture but Nest has helped change our perspective in the space.
This model has the ability to program itself, which helps you to save energy whenever you are not around. You can also control this smart thermostat from any location.
The Nest Learning Thermostat’s sleek design with its sharp display is an attractive feature to add to any home.

Pros

  • Offers improved learning capabilities
  • Saves energy with the auto-away feature
  • Large and sharp display

Cons

  • Does not offer a touchscreen feature

Sources

store.google.com
www.ecobee.com

Show CommentsClose Comments

Leave a comment