The ultimate Yale vs Schlage smart lock review. Both brands have a long history of producing secure, high quality locks and more recently, they are integrating them with smart home technology.
Smart locks offer you the comfort of secure, keyless, and remote access while providing the ability to monitor who enters and leaves your home at all times.
They provide peace of mind to homeowners, while offering the convenience of keyless entry or unlocking as you approach the door. They deliver all the security that standard locks offer including deadbolts and tamper protection.
Note that this article is written to give an unbiased view on each lock by evaluating their setup, security level, locking, unlocking, exterior design, interior design, top features, and product software.
Round 1 Head to Head
Yale Assure Lock
Model(s): YRD256-CBA-619
Designed to be the slimmest smart lock on the market, armed with a keypad for keyless entry. Comes with a doorSense sensor that notifies you when your door is either open or closed and auto-opens and closes as you approach.Schlage Encode™ Smart WiFi Deadbolt
Model(s): BE489WB CEN 622
The Schlage Encode Smart lock comes with built-in Wi-Fi and optional voice control offering hands-free convenience. It is designed in a variety of styles and finishes and comes with a built-in alarm, as well.Pros
- It can connect with almost all smart home hubs and security systems presently available in the market.
- Comes with a doorSense sensor that notifies you when your door is either open or closed and auto-opens and closes as you approach.
- The door unlocks automatically as you approach and auto-locks behind you.
Cons
- No physical backup key. Once your battery runs flat, you must recharge from outside via a 9v battery backup.
Pros
- Equipped with Amazon key for deliveries and video doorbell integration with Ring.
- Comes with built-in Wi-Fi, eliminating your need to purchase an additional hub for remote monitoring.
- Comes with a built-in alarm that detects potential security breaches around the lock.
Cons
- Zigbee and Z-Wave enabled devices can not connect directly unless an additional smart home hub is deployed due to the built-in Wi-Fi.
Installation, Power & Maintenance
Yale Assure Lock SL
Once you download the Yale app, it’s a straightforward process to complete the installation.
You can replace your existing deadbolt within minutes on a standard door using just a screwdriver.
Yale Assure Lock SL uses up to 4 AA batteries (included in the product box). Battery life is about a year with regular use.
Schlage Encode Smart Lock
With unique Snap ‘n Stay technology, you can snap the deadbolt onto the door to get both hands free during installation.
Installation is easy, requiring only a screwdriver to set up.
Schlage Encode Smart Lock uses up to 4 AA batteries (included in the product box). Battery life is about 6 months with standard use.
Security, Privacy, Deadbolts & Lock Grades
Yale Assure Lock SL
Comes with a doorSense sensor that notifies you when your door is either open or closed and auto-opens and closes as you approach.
Security grade 2 (A156.36 ANSI/BHMA).
Schlage Encode Smart Lock
Comes with built-in alarm technology that detects potential security breaches around the lock. Also armed with a low battery indicator which offers a warning for battery life in advance.
Security grade 1 (ANSI/BHMA A156.40-2015).
Design, Access & Extra Features
Yale Assure Lock SL
Designed to be the slimmest smart lock on the market. The Assure Lock is armed with a keypad for keyless entry. Comes with 25 user codes but you can set up to 250 user codes when combined with an optional Yale Smart module.
Schlage Encode Smart Lock
Comes with up to 100 user codes. Comes with one-time user codes, and time scheduled codes of 4-8 Digits.
Protocols, Smartphone App, Hubs & Integrations
Yale Assure Lock SL
Wi-Fi enabled via a hub, Yale connects with Google Assistant, Alexa, and Apple HomeKit for locking, unlocking, and checking lock status by just asking. Also uses Zigbee, Z-Wave, and Z-Wave Plus to connect. The unlocking feature is platform-dependent which means that it requires additional hubs if multiple types of connections need to be used by your smart home system.
Schlage Encode Smart Lock
It is Wi-Fi enabled and features a touchpad with easy one-touch locking that is resistant to fingerprint residue. It has optional voice control which offers hands-free convenience for voice-enabled usage. Also integrates with the Amazon Key app, Alarm.com app, Google Assistant, Alexa, Ring, and Schlage Home app.
Yale vs Schlage – Technical Comparison
| Yale Assure Lock | Schlage Encode Smart WiFi Deadbolt | |
| Dimension | 6” W x 6” L x 14” D | 2.26” W x 3” L x 5.47” D |
| Weight | 2.5 pounds | 2.8 pounds |
| Backset | 2 ¾” – 2 3/8” | 2 3/8″ – 2 3/4″ |
| Door Thickness | 1 3/8” – 2 ¼” | 1 3/8” – 1-3/4” |
| Warranty Description | Lifetime for Finish and Mechanical. 1 year for Electronics | Limited lifetime for Mechanical and Finish 3 year for Electronics |
| Power Source | Battery | Battery |
| Battery | 4 AA | 4 AA alkaline |
| Style | Lock Only | Century |
| Finish | Bronze | Matte |
| Mobile OS | iOS, Android, Windows | iOS, Android, Windows |
| Certification | A156.36 ANSI/BHMA Grade 2 | ANSI/BHMA A156.40-2015 Grade 1 |
The Verdict
Yale Assure Lock
Model(s): YRD256-CBA-619
Designed to be the slimmest smart lock on the market, armed with a keypad for keyless entry. Comes with a doorSense sensor that notifies you when your door is either open or closed and auto-opens and closes as you approach.Schlage Encode™ Smart WiFi Deadbolt
Model(s): BE489WB CEN 622
The Schlage Encode Smart lock comes with built-in Wi-Fi and optional voice control offering hands-free convenience. It is designed in a variety of styles and finishes and comes with a built-in alarm, as well.Round 2 Head to Head
Nest x Yale Lock
Model(s): RB-YRD540-WV-605
The Nest X Yale is a keyless smart lock relying on key codes and mobile app control for locking and unlocking. The lack of a keyhole is a security benefit as the lock is tamper-proof and can’t be snapped.Schlage Sense™ Smart Deadbolt
Model(s): BE479 V CAM 619
The Schlage Sense is designed with simple and convenient features with a mobile application for easy navigation. It can detect when the door is unlocked via the key or keypad and alerts you when it senses a security breach at your door.Pros
- Ability to remotely control your lock.
- User friendly, with Google Assistant support.
Cons
- Security grade lower than Schlage.
Pros
- ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 security rating.
- Easy installation procedure (15-20 minutes on average).
- Sleek and smudge-resistant keypad.
Cons
- Voice control or remote monitoring is only possible if the lock is paired with an additional Wi-Fi adapter.
Installation, Power & Maintenance
Nest x Yale
Comes with a removable door template and mounting screws. You can replace your existing deadbolt within minutes on a standard door using just a screwdriver. Full details included in the product manual. Equipped with 4 AA batteries with a one year life span.
Schlage Sense
Installation is easy with the use of just a screwdriver. A comprehensive installation manual is included in the product box. Comes with 4 AA alkaline batteries with a one year life span.
Security, Privacy, Deadbolts & Lock Grades
Nest x Yale
Keyless entry, only accessible via generated codes and mobile app controls. Supports one owner plus nine additional people with full access. Can generate up to 20 Passcodes” for visitors with scheduled timing code possible. Lock is ANSI/BHMA A156.36, Grade 2.
Schlage Sense
Comes with a backup key and can store up to 30 access codes at a time. However, proximity unlocking is not possible. This lock is ANSI/BHMA A156.40-2015, Grade 1 with a built-in alarm that goes off when tampering is detected.
Design, Access & Extra Features
Nest x Yale
Armed with remote access for unlocking your door. It comes with a passcode option which requires Nest Connect/Nest Guard for connection via Wi-Fi. Supports 10 users with full access and up to 20 visitors with passcodes.
Locks automatically when Nest knows you are away with a keyless deadbolt for security and tamper protection.
Schlage Sense
Sleekly designed to lock and unlock from anywhere via Schlage Sense Wi-Fi adapter (sold separately). Can store up to 30 access codes at a time.
Protocols, Smartphone App, Hubs & Integrations
Nest x Yale
Uses 802.15.4 (2.4GHz) Bluetooth, and Wi-Fi for connection. You will need the Nest for remote control via your smartphone. This lock supports Google Assistant and smartwatch pairing.
Schlage Sense
Uses Apple HomeKit, Bluetooth, and Wi-Fi via hub for connection, and can be paired with your smartphone. Alexa support, Google Assistant support, and HomeKit & Siri support are also available.
Yale vs Schlage – Technical Comparison
| Nest x Yale | Schlage Sense | |
| Lock Dimension | 6.1” W x 11.8” L x 5.4” D | 4.5” W x 3” L x 8” D |
| Weight | 2.26 pounds | 3.4 pounds |
| Backset | 2 3/8″ – 2 3/4″ | 2 3/8″ – 2 3/4″ |
| Door Thickness | 1 3/8″ – 2 1/4″ | 1 3/8″ – 1 3/4″ |
| Warranty Description | Lifetime for Finish and Mechanical. 2 years for Electronics | Limited lifetime for Mechanical and Finish 3 years for Electronics |
| Power Source | Battery | Battery |
| Battery | 4 AA | 4 AA alkaline |
| Mobile OS | iOS, Android, Windows | iOS, Android, Windows |
| Interior Dimension | 2.78” W x 7.03” L x 2.02” D | 3″ W x 8″ L x 2″ D |
| Exterior Dimension | 2.59” W x 4.59” L x 0.80” D | 3″ W x 5″ L x 1″ D |
The Verdict
Nest x Yale Lock
Model(s): RB-YRD540-WV-605
The Nest X Yale is a keyless smart lock relying on key codes and mobile app control for locking and unlocking. The lack of a keyhole is a security benefit as the lock is tamper-proof and can’t be snapped.Schlage Sense™ Smart Deadbolt
Model(s): BE479 V CAM 619
The Schlage Sense is designed with simple and convenient features with a mobile application for easy navigation. It can detect when the door is unlocked via the key or keypad and alerts you when it senses a security breach at your door.Round 3 – Z-Wave Smart Locks Head to Head
Yale Assure Lock with Z-Wave
Model(s): YRD226-ZW2-619
Keyless door lock with a 30-second auto-lock after opening. Has an easy one-touch locking feature with up to 16 customization codes for your family and friends. Designed to work with Z-Wave smart home and other smart home hubs.Schlage Connect™ Smart Deadbolt
Model(s): BE469ZP CAM 622
Built with the highest security rating and comes in multiple styles to give buyers variety. It is neatly designed with two sections, the top of the hardware houses the screen while the bottom is home to the keyhole for regular keys. Can effortlessly connect with Z-wave and Zigbee for smart features.Pros
- It comes with a 9v battery for emergency charging.
- The lock has a built-in alarm system that disables the keypad when wrong codes are entered several times.
Cons
- Security grade lower than Schlage.
Pros
- Program up to 30 unique codes.
- Works with numerous security services and smart home hubs.
- Comes in multiple styles and colors
Cons
- No dedicated app, requires a Z-Wave hub.
Installation, Power & Maintenance
Yale Assure Lock SL with Z-Wave
You can replace the existing deadbolt with just a screwdriver within minutes and the lock can fit on standard doors. Uses 4 AA batteries which are included with your purchase.
Schlage Connect Smart Deadbolt
Unique Snap ‘n Stay technology snaps the deadbolt onto the door to free both hands during installation. Easy to install within minutes with just a screwdriver and you only need 4 AA batteries.
Security, Privacy, Deadbolts & Lock Grades
Yale Assure Lock SL with Z-Wave
Comes with a built-in alarm that goes off when wrong codes are entered multiple times. Keyless with 30-seconds auto-lock timing after exit or entry.
It is rated ASNI/BHMA Grade 2. Also equipped with remote monitoring through Z-Wave but must be connected to Wi-Fi (sold separately).
Schlage Connect Smart Deadbolt
Equipped with an alarm system that rings when there is a potential breach of the lock. It beeps when locked, unlocked, or intruded.
Rated ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 (Highest security rating).
Design, Access & Extra Features
Yale Assure Lock SL with Z-Wave
Has an easy one-touch locking feature with up to 16 customizable codes for visiting friends and family. You can manage this smart lock from anywhere when connected to an alarm system or a smart home hub.
Schlage Connect Smart Deadbolt
Comes in different styles and colors for multiple buying choices with illumination for easy keypad spotting. Can be programmed with up to 30 unique access codes for visiting friends and family
Protocols, Smartphone App, Hubs & Integrations
Yale Assure Lock SL with Z-Wave
Integrates with a variety of hubs and devices including Apple HomePod, Apple TV 4th Gen, VeraEdge, SmartThings, Honeywell, Iris, and VeraPlus, Amazon Echo and Amazon Cloud Cam.
Google Assistant, Alexa, Homekit and Siri are also supported.
Schlage Connect Smart Deadbolt
Integrate with a variety of hubs and devices including Wink Hub 1, Wink Hub 2, VeraEdge, VeraPlus, Samsung SmartThings Hub 1st Gen, Samsung SmartThings Hub.
Alexa and Google Assistant are also supported.
Yale vs Schlage – Technical Comparison
| Yale Assure Lock SL with Z-Wave | Schlage Connect Smart Deadbolt | |
| Lock Dimension | 1” W x 2.5” L x 3” D | 4.5” W x 3” L x 8” D |
| Weight | 3 pounds | 3.8 pounds |
| Backset | 2 3/8″ – 2 3/4″ | 2 3/8″ – 2 3/4″ |
| Door Thickness | 1 3/8″ – 2 1/4″ | 1 3/8″ – 1 3/4″ |
| Warranty Description | Lifetime for Finish and Mechanical. 1 year for Electronics | Limited lifetime for Mechanical and Finish 3 years for Electronics |
| Power Source | Battery | Battery |
| Battery | 4 AA | 4 AA alkaline |
| Mobile OS | iOS, Android, Windows | iOS, Android, Windows |
| Interior Dimension | 2.78” W x 7.03” L x 2.02” D | 3″ W x 8″ L x 2″ D |
| Exterior Dimension | 2.59” W x 4.59” L x 0.80” D | 3″ W x 5″ L x 1″ D |
The Verdict
Yale Assure Lock with Z-Wave
Model(s): YRD226-ZW2-619
Keyless door lock with a 30-second auto-lock after opening. Has an easy one-touch locking feature with up to 16 customization codes for your family and friends. Designed to work with Z-Wave smart home and other smart home hubs.Schlage Connect™ Smart Deadbolt
Model(s): BE469ZP CAM 622
Built with the highest security rating and comes in multiple styles to give buyers variety. It is neatly designed with two sections, the top of the hardware houses the screen while the bottom is home to the keyhole for regular keys. Can effortlessly connect with Z-wave and Zigbee for smart features.